Amazing chocolate covered cherries yield 120 joy

Oh, the nostalgia wrapped up in a perfect piece of homemade candy! There’s just nothing that compares to biting into a store-bought treat and wishing you could recreate that magic yourself, right? Well, let me tell you—you absolutely can, and it’s easier than you think. Today, we are making my favorite holiday indulgence: beautiful **chocolate covered cherries**. Forget about those dry, chalky ones; we are aiming for that luscious, gooey liquid center cordial experience! When I started Taste This Plate, my goal was proving we could make *incredible*, impressive sweets without all the fuss. This recipe is the perfect example of that philosophy. You’ll be amazed at how you pulled off something that tastes so gourmet!

Why You Will Love These Homemade Chocolate Covered Cherry Cordials

Honestly, these are going straight into the ‘must-make-every-year’ category. They are just too easy and look so fancy! If you loved treating yourself with my gooey butter pecan cake, these are right up that same indulgent alley.

• They deliver that signature liquid center chocolate cherries experience without needing complicated tempering.
• This is a fantastic, easy cherry cordial recipe, perfect for beginners in gourmet candy making.
• They look incredibly impressive when lined up on a platter—truly homemade gourmet gifts material!
• We rely on simple maraschino cherry candy components, meaning you don’t need fresh fruit on hand.
• Perfect for your holiday candy recipes or your special Valentine Day candy ideas list!

Ingredients for the Best Chocolate Covered Cherry Cordials

When it comes to candy, the quality of what goes in really shows up on the outside. Don’t skip the little details here—like making sure those cherries are dry! That’s how we get that perfect shell around our chocolate covered cherries.

For the Fondant Filling and Cherries

We are keeping this simple, relying on that jar of maraschino cherries!

• One 10-ounce jar of maraschino cherries—and remember, drain these *very* well!
• Powdered sugar (about half a cup).
• Just a whisper of corn syrup.
• A tiny splash of almond extract. It really wakes up the cherry flavor, trust me!

For the Rich Chocolate Coating

This is where we decide on the final look. If you want that decadent, almost bitter snap to balance all that sweet, go for dark chocolate. It always feels more gourmet candy making level!

• 12 ounces of semi-sweet chocolate—make sure it’s good quality!
• One tablespoon of shortening or coconut oil. This is optional, but it helps create the smoothest finish possible.

How to Make Liquid Center Chocolate Cherries: Step-by-Step Instructions

This is where the magic happens, but let me warn you: candy demands patience! The key to success when making these chocolate covered cherries is setting that fondant firmly before we introduce it to the hot chocolate. Don’t rush the chilling steps, or you’ll end up with a runny mess instead of perfect cordials. Once you master this, you’re set for all kinds of wonderful holiday treats, maybe even something like my easy apple snickerdoodle dump cake!

Preparing the Cherries and Fondant Base

First things first: dry those cherries. Seriously. Lay your drained maraschino cherries out on a thick layer of paper towels and just pat them like you’re dusting fine china. If they are damp, the fondant won’t stick, and that’s a fail right there. While they dry, quickly whip up your filling. Mix the powdered sugar, corn syrup, and almond extract until you have a stiff, thick paste. Now, take one dried cherry and carefully wrap a spoonful of that paste around it. You only need enough to seal it in—we want the cherry juice to create that signature melt later!

Chilling and Setting the Chocolate Covered Cherries

Once each cherry is encased in fondant, arrange them on a sheet of parchment paper. They absolutely must chill now. Stick them in the fridge for at least 30 minutes, or just let them sit out for two hours if your kitchen isn’t too warm. This hardening step is vital. If the fondant balls are soft when they hit the melted chocolate, everything melts together, and you miss out on that beautiful texture contrast.

The Simple Chocolate Dipping Guide

Time for dipping! Melt your semi-sweet chocolate slowly. I use the microwave in 30-second bursts, stirring well each time so I don’t burn the edges. If you’ve got that optional shortening or coconut oil, stir it in now; it makes the chocolate so much silkier, which is a huge confidence booster when you’re trying out gourmet candy making for the first time. Pop one chilled cherry in, get it totally covered, use a fork to lift it off, and let that extra chocolate drip right back into the bowl. Don’t forget to check out the dipping tips over at Buttery Sweet for technique inspiration! Place them back on the parchment to set up completely. A quick trip to the fridge speeds this up, and then you’re done!

Tips for Success When Making Chocolate Dipped Cherries

When you’re aiming for that melt-in-your-mouth experience, the tiny details make all the difference. I’ve learned a few tricks over the years managing my own kitchen experiments—and trust me, I’ve made plenty of messy chocolate catastrophes so you don’t have to! These tips will help elevate your chocolate covered cherries from ‘homemade’ to genuinely respectable.

First up, let’s talk about the moisture level again. This is the number one rule for getting that perfect cordial effect.

• Don’t Over-Dry the Cherries: Yes, I just told you to dry them well, but there’s a balance! You want the *outside* surface dry so the fondant sticks, but you need to leave a little bit of that sweet maraschino juice inside. That residual juice interacting with the fondant during setting is what creates that glorious liquid surprise when you bite in. If you squeeze them until they are rock hard, they’ll taste like dry maraschino candy instead of a cordial!
• Chill Hard Before Dipping: I cannot stress this enough. Your fondant-covered cherries need to be cold and firm before they even look at hot chocolate. If they are even slightly soft, the heat from the chocolate will warm the fondant up too fast, and you’ll end up with a melted puddle instead of a neat chocolate shell. Sometimes I even pop them back in the fridge for 10 minutes right before I start dipping clusters.
• Tempering Made Easy with Oil: If you really want professional-looking sheen, adding that small amount of shortening or coconut oil to your melted chocolate (as noted in the ingredients) is huge. It lowers the viscosity, making the chocolate thinner and easier to coat evenly. Plus, it really helps the chocolate set up hard and glossy without needing a full tempering process. It’s my little cheat code for beautiful chocolate dipped cherries.

If you want some great inspiration on how to get that perfect shell, take a peek at how the folks over at CookThink approach their classic recipes. And honestly, practicing good dipping form is just like practicing scooping batter for my classic chocolate chip cookies—the more you do it, the faster and neater you become!

Variations for Your Chocolate Covered Cherries

One of the best parts about making things yourself, like these fantastic **chocolate covered cherries**, is that you get to be the boss of the flavor profile! If semi-sweet isn’t your absolute favorite, don’t even worry about it. We’re aiming for decadent chocolate desserts here, and that means using what makes *you* happiest.

Switching up the chocolate coating is incredibly simple—it’s still just melting and dipping, which is the fun part! If you prefer something sweeter, definitely go for milk chocolate. It pairs beautifully with the bright cherry flavor and makes for a wonderful, old-fashioned taste. On the flip side, if you’re looking for something truly professional and rich, milk chocolate’s counterpart, dark chocolate, is the way to go.

I actually prefer using a higher quality dark chocolate when I make these for holiday platters because the slight bitterness cuts through the syrupiness of the maraschino just perfectly. It elevates the whole experience!

What about inside? While this recipe is designed for that specific liquid cordial center, you can add little twists to the fondant if you feel adventurous. A tiny pinch of orange zest mixed into the powdered sugar paste works wonders! It gives it a lovely bright note that works so well with the almond extract we already have in there. Think of the possibilities—it’s almost like creating a whole new flavor profile, similar to how I sneak in extra cinnamon crunch when I make my cinnamon crunch banana bread!

Remember, these are your candies. Whether you stick to the classic simple coating or try a drizzle of white chocolate over a dark chocolate base for decoration, the core recipe is so forgiving you can experiment freely!

Storage & Gifting Homemade Chocolate Covered Cherries

Now that you’ve made these gorgeous candies, the big question is how to keep them fresh—and how to show them off! These **chocolate covered cherries** are beautiful enough to be top-tier homemade gourmet gifts, especially leading up to Christmas or Valentine’s Day. But unlike my baked goods, these enjoy a slightly different storage environment.

The good news is that because these are mostly centered around sugar and chocolate, they actually store beautifully at cool room temperature! You don’t need to dedicate precious fridge space to them, which is great when you’re trying to cram everything in for a big party.

You want to keep them in an airtight container. Why airtight? Because chocolate loves grabbing onto smells from whatever else is lurking in your pantry. We don’t want your beautiful cordials smelling like last night’s onions, right? The recipe notes suggest they stay perfect for up to a week stored this way. That’s plenty of time for you to enjoy them before they disappear (which they probably will).

When you’re getting them ready to give away as gifts, presentation completely changes the game. You can set them in small cupcake liners inside a decorative tin. This keeps them from smacking into each other and cracking that beautiful chocolate shell. They look so much more expensive than they actually are, which is the best kind of cooking win!

If you’ve made a massive batch for gifting, like I often do when preparing for the holidays, you might want to look into some proper holiday packaging ideas. Sometimes I wrap small tins of these candies with lovely ribbon after checking out some inspiration over at my post on Christmas canning gifts. They look rustic and elegant all at once.

If you’re curious about how the liquid center holds up over a week, or if you want to see another fantastic way to approach this classic, check out the tips on One Sweet Mama—they always have such reliable candy advice!

Frequently Asked Questions About Chocolate Covered Cherries

I know when I first started diving into making my own chocolate covered cherries, I had a million questions buzzing around my head. It’s tricky stuff, but once you nail a few key points, it becomes second nature. We want these to be the star of your dessert platter, not a sticky mess!

Can I use fresh cherries instead of maraschino cherries for these chocolate covered cherries?

That’s a great question, and honestly, it comes down to what kind of candy you want! This specific easy cherry cordial recipe is built around the sweet, shelf-stable flavor and texture of good ol’ jarred maraschino cherries. If you use fresh cherries, you’d have to boil them down, candy them, or cook them with sugar for ages to get them to the right texture so they don’t leak water into your fondant later. For this recipe, stick to the jarred ones—they give you that authentic, iconic look and feel of classic maraschino cherry candy without hours of extra work.

What is the secret to getting a true liquid center in my cherry cordials?

This is the absolute key to avoiding dry candy! While we pat the cherries dry so the fondant sticks, you must resist the urge to squeeze every single drop of juice out. Think about it: that little pocket of residual syrup is what creates that wonderful melt-in-your-mouth moment when you bite through the coating and the fondant. That syrup mixes just a little bit with the fondant as everything sits, turning it into the luxurious, slightly weeping center that makes these liquid center chocolate cherries famous. Don’t squeeze them dry; just blot them gently!

How do I stop the chocolate from seizing when making these chocolate dipped cherries?

Oh, the dreaded seize! It’s the absolute fastest way to ruin a batch of candy, and it happens when even a tiny droplet of water meets your smoothly melted chocolate. Water turns your beautiful sauce into a thick, grainy paste almost instantly. My biggest tip for these chocolate dipped cherries is strictly discipline: make sure your bowls, utensils, and even the air above the melting chocolate are completely dry. If you microwave it, don’t walk away! Stir constantly. If you find the chocolate is heating up a bit too fast and looks stiff, just stir in that optional tablespoon of shortening or coconut oil—it disrupts the structure just enough without adding water, giving you a smoother, more manageable coating.

If you want to check out some other great techniques for keeping your coatings shiny and smooth, I found some helpful tips over at Taste This Plate that explain how different fats affect chocolate texture!

Nutritional Estimates for Chocolate Covered Cherries

Since we’re making homemade candy, we know we aren’t exactly aiming for a health food, but it’s always good to have a ballpark idea of what’s in that gorgeous bite! These estimates are based on the ingredients list and standard chocolate composition, but please know that the actual numbers can shift depending on the brand of semi-sweet chocolate you decide to splurge on. After all, even something as simple as a chocolate-dipped treat tastes different depending on the quality of the cocoa!

If you’re wondering about the breakdown, here is what you can generally expect per single piece of chocolate covered cherries:

• Serving Size: 1 piece
• Calories: About 120
• Total Fat: 6g (Be sure to watch that saturated fat content!)
• Carbohydrates: 17g
• Sugar: 15g (That’s where that lovely cordial sweetness comes from!)
• Protein: 1g
• Sodium: 5mg
• Cholesterol: 2mg

Remember, these are just estimates, especially if you decide to use dark chocolate or switch up the type of syrup you use. If you’re prepping these for a holiday gathering or making them alongside something like my bacon Gruyère egg bites for brunch, it’s helpful to have these labels in mind for your guests!

Share Your Homemade Gourmet Gifts

And there you have it! You have successfully created your own batch of decadent, melt-in-your-mouth chocolate covered cherries. Seriously, take a moment and admire them! Doesn’t it feel so good to know you whipped up something that looks straight out of a fancy candy shop? I hope these become a staple for your holiday baking—they genuinely are one of the best homemade gourmet gifts you can give.

Now that you’ve spent the time to make these beauties, I really, really want to hear how they turned out for you! Did the chocolate dip smoothly? Did you manage to keep just enough juice inside for that magnificent liquid center? Please don’t be shy!

Drop a star rating right here on the recipe card below—it helps other home cooks know they can trust this recipe just as you have. And if you have a moment, leaving a comment is my favorite part of running this site. Tell me what chocolate you used, or if you tried that little orange zest trick I mentioned earlier!

If you happen to snap a picture of your perfectly coated cordials—maybe they are nestled next to a stack of cookies or boxed up nicely for gifting—I’d love to see them! You can tag me on social media, or if you need to send photos directly, you can always get in touch through my contact page. Seeing your successes is truly what keeps me inspired in the kitchen every single day.

If you’re still looking for inspiration on presentation or other fun holiday ideas, take a look at how the folks at Spaceships and Laser Beams present their festive treats. Happy making, and enjoy every single delicious bite!

Print